Maintaining a clean pool sparkling on the ground is not a chore. This article will help you choose the best pool cleaners above ground for your needs. Consider factors such as swimming pool size, debris, budget, and desired automation level. Whether you like robotic detergents, suction, or pressure, we will break down the pros and cons of each type to ensure you find the perfect solution for your pool cleaning needs.
What makes above-ground pool cleaners different?
The unique characteristics of above-ground pools, which differ from in-ground pools in several important ways, specifically inform the design of above-ground pool cleaners.
- Design and Compatibility: Engineers design above-ground pool cleaners to fit the unique dimensions and shapes of above-ground pools, which frequently have shallower depths and flat bottoms than in-ground pools.
- Lightweight and maneuverable: Because cleaners are typically lighter in weight and more maneuverable to accommodate the smaller size and lower water volume of above-ground pools.
- Gentler on Pool Liners: Designed to minimize the risk of damage during cleaning, above-ground pool cleaners are gentle on the vinyl pool liners commonly used in above-ground pools.
Key Features of Top Above Ground Pool Cleaners
Compact Design: Above-ground pool cleaners frequently have a compact and streamlined design, allowing them to navigate tight corners and small spaces efficiently.
Simple Setup: Many above-ground pool cleaners feature easy installation and setup, making them user-friendly for pool owners without extensive technical knowledge.
Effective Cleaning Performance: Powerful suction or scrubbing mechanisms, despite their smaller size, equip top above-ground pool cleaners to effectively remove dirt, debris, and algae from pool surfaces.
Adjustable Cleaning Patterns: Some models offer adjustable cleaning patterns or programmable cleaning cycles to customize cleaning coverage and optimize efficiency.
Understanding the Mechanics: How They Work?
Suction Cleaners: These cleaners use the pool’s filtration system to create suction, which pulls debris into a filter bag or basket. They move around the pool randomly, relying on water flow for navigation and cleaning.
Pressure-Side Cleaners: Pressure-side cleaners use water pressure from the pool’s pump to propel the cleaner and collect debris. They typically require a separate booster pump for optimal performance.
Robotic Cleaners: Robotic above-ground pool cleaners operate independently of the pool’s filtration system, using their own motor and filtration system to clean the pool efficiently. They are highly efficient and offer advanced features such as smart navigation and programmable cleaning cycles.
Comparing Above Ground vs. In-Ground Pool Cleaners
| Feature | Above-Ground Cleaners | In-Ground Cleaners |
| Pool Compatibility | Designed specifically for above-ground pools | Designed specifically for in-ground pools (may damage above-ground pool liners) |
| Size and Weight | Lighter and more compact (easier to handle and store) | Heavier and bulkier due to more complex features |
| Navigation | Simpler, programmed, or random movement patterns, some with basic wall-climbing abilities | Advanced navigation systems with obstacle avoidance for thorough cleaning |
| Cleaning Coverage | Primarily, it focuses on skimming the pool floor and collecting debris. | Cleans floors, walls, and waterlines for comprehensive cleaning |
| Power Source | Electric (direct connection to a GFCI outlet or rechargeable battery) | Electric (direct connection) |
| Price | Generally more affordable | Wide price range, with high-end models being more expensive. |
When making a decision, consider these factors:
- Pool Type: Always choose a cleaner designed for your specific pool type (above-ground or in-ground).
- Pool Size: To ensure optimal cleaning performance, match the cleaner’s capacity to your pool’s size.
- Budget: Above-ground cleaners generally offer a good value, while in-ground vacuums cater to a wider budget range depending on desired features.
- Desired Cleaning Level: If a thorough cleaning of floors, walls, and waterlines is required, an in-ground cleaner may be a better choice. For basic floor cleaning, an above-ground cleaner can suffice.
Types of Above Ground Pool Cleaners to Consider
When considering above-ground pool cleaners, you have several options to choose from, each with its own set of pros and cons.
- Suction-Side Cleaners: These cleaners attach to the suction port or skimmer of your pool’s filtration system and use the pool’s suction power to move around and collect debris.
- Pressure-Side Cleaners: These cleaners connect to the pressure side of your pool’s circulation system and use water pressure to propel the cleaner around the pool while collecting debris.
- Robotic Pool Cleaners: These standalone cleaners operate independently of your pool’s filtration system and use their own power source and filtration system to clean the pool efficiently.
Suction-Side Cleaners: Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Affordable: Suction-side cleaners are often more budget-friendly compared to other types of cleaners.
- Easy to install: They typically require minimal setup and installation, making them user-friendly for pool owners.
- Low Maintenance: Since they rely on the pool’s filtration system, they have fewer moving parts and require less maintenance.
Cons:
- Dependent on Pool Filtration: They may be less effective in pools with weak filtration systems or larger debris loads.
- May Clog: Suction-side cleaners can sometimes become clogged with large debris, requiring manual intervention to unclog them.
- Limited Cleaning Coverage: They may not cover the entire pool surface efficiently, especially in larger or irregularly shaped pools.
Pressure-Side Cleaners: Are They Worth It?
Pros:
- Effective Debris Removal: Pressure-side cleaners can handle larger debris and provide a thorough cleaning of pool surfaces.
- Independent Operation: They operate independently of the pool’s filtration system, reducing strain on the filtration system and improving overall circulation.
- Built-in Debris Bag: Many pressure-side cleaners come with built-in debris bags, making it easy to empty and clean them.
Cons:
- Higher Cost: Pressure-side cleaners tend to be more expensive upfront compared to suction-side cleaners.
- Booster Pump: For optimal performance, they may need a separate booster pump, adding to the initial cost and energy consumption.
- More Complex Installation: Installation may be more involved compared to suction-side cleaners, especially if a booster pump is needed.
Robotic Pool Cleaners: The Future of Pool Maintenance?
Pros:
- Efficient Cleaning: Robotic cleaners efficiently and thoroughly clean pool surfaces, walls, and floors.
- Independent Operation: They operate independently of the pool’s filtration system, reducing strain on the filtration system and improving overall circulation.
- Advanced Features: Many robotic cleaners come with advanced features such as smart navigation, programmable cleaning cycles, and remote control options.
Cons:
- Higher Cost: Robotic cleaners tend to be the most expensive option upfront compared to suction-side and pressure-side cleaners.
- Requires Power Source: They need access to a power outlet for operation, which may limit flexibility in placement and usage.
- Potential Maintenance: While robotic cleaners have their own filtration system, they may require occasional maintenance, such as emptying and cleaning the filter cartridge.
How do you choose the right cleaner for your pool Size and Type?
When selecting the right cleaner for your pool size and type, consider factors such as pool dimensions, surface material, and the cleaner’s capacity to ensure effective and efficient cleaning.
Considering Pool Size and Cleaner Capacity
Assess Pool Size: Measure your pool’s dimensions, including length, width, and depth, to determine its size in gallons or square footage.
Determine Debris Load: Consider factors such as nearby trees, vegetation, and usage patterns to assess the potential debris load in your pool.
Choose Cleaner Capacity: Select a cleaner with the appropriate capacity to effectively handle your pool’s size and debris load. Larger pools or those with heavy debris may require cleaners with larger debris bags or higher suction power.
Check Coverage Area: Ensure that the cleaner’s coverage area matches the size of your pool.
Matching Cleaner Type to Pool Surface Material
Vinyl Liner Pools: If your pool has a vinyl liner, choose a cleaner that is gentle on delicate surfaces to avoid damage or tearing. Suction-side or robotic cleaners with soft brushes or rollers are ideal for vinyl liner pools.
Fiberglass Pools: Fiberglass pools have smooth surfaces that are prone to algae growth. Consider cleaning with scrubbing brushes or rotating scrubbers.
Concrete or Gunite Pools: Concrete and gunite pools have rough surfaces that can trap dirt and debris. Opt for a cleaner with strong suction power or pressure-side cleaning to effectively clean and remove debris from these surfaces.
Tile Pools: To prevent damage to the grout and tile surfaces, careful cleaning is required. Choose a cleaner with adjustable cleaning settings or brush types that can effectively clean tile surfaces without causing damage.
Here’s a table summarizing the suitability of each cleaner type based on pool size and surface material:
| Feature | Suction-Side Cleaner | Pressure-Side Cleaner | Robotic Cleaner |
| Ideal pool size | Small to medium | Medium to Large | Small to Large |
| Not recommended for | Large Pools | Metal Walls | – |
| Compatible Surface | Vinyl Liners | Vinyl liners (except powerful models for metal walls) | Vinyl Liners, Metal Walls |
Maintenance Tips for Prolonging the Life of Your Pool Cleaner
Regular cleaning and care tips
Clean Debris Regularly: Empty the debris bag or filter cartridge of your pool cleaner after each use to prevent clogging and maintain suction efficiency.
Inspect Brushes and Rollers: Check the brushes or rollers of your cleaner for signs of wear or damage regularly. Replace them if they become worn or ineffective.
Clean Filter and Filters: Rinse and clean the filter or filters of your pool cleaner according to the manufacturer’s instructions. Clogged filters can reduce cleaning efficiency and strain the cleaner’s motor.
Check Hose and Connections: Inspect the hoses, connections, and fittings of your pool cleaner for leaks, cracks, or damage. Replace any damaged components to prevent water leakage and ensure proper operation.
Store Properly: Store your pool cleaner in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight when not in use. Avoid leaving it exposed to harsh weather conditions, which can degrade its components over time.
Common Issues and Troubleshooting
Loss of Suction: If your pool cleaner is experiencing a loss of suction, check for clogs in the debris bag, filter, or hoses. Clean or unclog any blocked components to restore suction.
Stuck or Jammed Cleaner: If your cleaner gets stuck or jammed in one area of the pool, check for obstructions such as leaves, debris, or pool toys. Remove any obstacles to allow the cleaner to resume normal operation.
Poor Cleaning Performance: If your pool cleaner is not effectively cleaning the pool surface, check the brushes or rollers for wear or damage. Replace worn components and ensure they are properly aligned for optimal cleaning.
Motor or Power Issues: If your pool cleaner is not turning on or experiencing power issues, check the power supply, cord, and connections for damage or defects. Ensure the power source is functioning correctly before troubleshooting further.
Erratic Movement: If your cleaner is moving erratically or not following a consistent cleaning pattern, check for tangled or twisted hoses, which can impede movement. Straighten out any kinks or tangles to improve navigation.
Budgeting for Your Above Ground Pool Cleaner
When budgeting for an above-ground pool cleaner, it’s essential to consider various factors such as price points, features, and cost-effective options that fit within your budget.
Understanding price points and features
Entry-Level Cleaners: Entry-level above-ground pool cleaners typically have basic features and are more budget-friendly. These cleaners often rely on simple suction or manual operation for cleaning and may lack advanced features such as programmable cleaning cycles or smart navigation.
Mid-Range Cleaners: Mid-range cleaners offer a balance between price and features, providing more advanced cleaning performance and convenience compared to entry-level options. These cleaners may include features such as programmable cleaning cycles, adjustable cleaning patterns, and enhanced debris removal capabilities.
High-End Cleaners: High-end above-ground pool cleaners are equipped with advanced features and technology for superior cleaning performance and convenience. These cleaners often include features such as smart navigation, remote control operation, and advanced filtration systems for efficient debris removal and water clarity.
Cost-Effective Options for Every Budget
Suction-Side Cleaners: Suction-side cleaners are often the most budget-friendly option for above-ground pool owners. These cleaners rely on the pool’s filtration system for suction and movement, making them more affordable compared to robotic or pressure-side cleaners.
Robotic Cleaners: While robotic cleaners tend to have a higher upfront cost, they offer cost-effective benefits in the long run. Robotic cleaners operate independently of the pool’s filtration system, reducing strain on the system and potentially lowering energy costs over time.
Mid-Range Models: Look for mid-range above-ground pool cleaners that offer a balance between price and features. These cleaners provide effective cleaning performance and convenience without breaking the bank.
Consider Refurbished or Discounted Models: Many retailers offer refurbished or discounted above-ground pool cleaners at a lower price point. These models may have minor cosmetic defects or be previous-year models, but they still offer reliable performance at a reduced cost.
Choosing the right above ground pool cleaner depends on your specific needs and budget. By considering the factors outlined above, you can make an informed decision and enjoy a cleaner, more enjoyable pool experience.
Meet David Thomas, a seasoned professional with nearly 8 years of experience specializing in inspecting and resolving issues related to swimming pools. With his expertise and meticulous attention to detail, David ensures the safety and functionality of pools, making them a refreshing oasis for all to enjoy. Whether it’s troubleshooting equipment or maintaining water quality, David’s proficiency guarantees top-notch solutions tailored to meet every pool owner’s needs.